Butter substitute amounts for baking and cooking

Melted butter is easier to replace than cold butter in pastry. Read the method before choosing what's going into your bowl.

Quick answer

For a butter substitute in recipes using melted butter, use about 3/4 cup (177 ml) neutral oil for every 1 cup (227 g) butter. By weight, use about 80 g oil per 100 g butter. This suits muffins, quick breads and brownies made by stirring. For creamed cookies or cakes, choose a baking block with at least 80% fat, used 1:1. Cold pastry needs more care.

Match the swap to the method

These amounts replace 1 US cup (227 g) butter. For swaps measured by volume, a US cup holds 236.6 ml. Sunflower or canola oil keeps the flavor neutral; olive oil brings its own taste. A spread that tastes good on toast may contain too much water for baking.

SwapAmount per 1 cup (227 g) butterBest forWhat changes
Neutral oilAbout 3/4 cup (177 ml)Stirred muffins, quick breads, browniesLess butter flavor; unsuitable for creaming
Margarine or baking block, at least 80% fat1 cup (236.6 ml), used 1:1Cookies and cakesFlavor depends on the product
Vegan butter block1 cup (236.6 ml), used 1:1Baking with a solid butter replacementDifferent flavor; check the recipe's method
Vegetable shortening1 cup (236.6 ml), 1:1 by volumeCookies and flaky pastryLess cookie spread; no butter flavor or water; add a pinch of salt
Coconut oil1 cup (236.6 ml), used 1:1Creaming or pastry when solid; stirred batter when meltedRefined has no coconut taste; texture can differ
Ghee1 cup (236.6 ml), used 1:1Cooking and fryingNutty taste; almost pure fat

For butter measured in sticks, check the butter cups and sticks conversion before choosing a replacement. Convert the amount the recipe actually calls for, then apply the swap.

Why oil needs a smaller amount

Butter is at least 80% milk fat, with about 16-18% water plus milk solids. Oil supplies fat without that water. Replacing melted butter with the same volume of oil can leave a batter greasy, so the oil amount is smaller.

Use either the volume ratio or the weight ratio in the answer. They are approximate kitchen conversions, so don't mix the methods halfway through. Weighing the butter amount and using the weight ratio is handy when your butter comes in a block.

Read the mixing instructions before using oil as a substitute for butter in baking. A recipe that says to stir melted butter into wet ingredients is a better candidate than one that begins by beating softened butter with sugar.

Butter also traps air and makes steam

When you cream softened butter and sugar, the solid fat traps air. Liquid oil cannot do that job. Many cookies and classic butter cakes depend on this step, so an oil swap can change their spread and texture even if the fat amount looks reasonable.

Cold butter behaves differently again. Pieces or layers of butter sit in the dough, and the water turns to steam during baking. That helps lift flaky pastry. Butter's milk solids also brown and give it a flavor you won't get from plain oil.

Keep the recipe's raising agents as written. Extra baking powder won't make liquid oil behave like creamed butter. If you're also missing that ingredient, check the baking powder substitute amounts separately.

Fruit and yogurt replace only part of the butter

Greek yogurt, applesauce or mashed banana can replace up to half the butter in muffins and quick breads. Keep the remaining butter. Expect a denser, more cake-like result rather than the same crumb as the original recipe.

Banana brings a noticeable flavor, so choose it for something you'd enjoy tasting of banana. These partial swaps are poor choices for flaky pastry or cookies where the butter's texture is doing much of the work.

What to buy outside the US

In the UK or Australia, look for a baking block and check the fat content. The words margarine or spread alone don't tell you whether it will work. Low-fat spreads contain extra water and can fail in baking; choose at least 80% fat for the margarine swap.

If you're shopping in another language, butter is beurre in French, burro in Italian and mantequilla in Spanish. French doux means unsalted and demi-sel means salted. In Indonesian everyday speech, mentega can mean margarine; an American recipe calling for butter means dairy butter.

When to keep the butter

For puff pastry, scones or pie crust, avoid replacing cold butter with liquid oil. A solid replacement can still change the flavor and handling. If the bake depends on carefully folded butter layers, use the specified butter or find a recipe developed for your replacement.

When butter is the main flavor, as in a butter sauce, a neutral fat won't taste the same. For cooking and frying where a nutty taste fits, ghee works 1:1, but it doesn't supply the water of whole butter.

Questions

Can I use oil instead of butter in cookies?

If the recipe creams butter with sugar, oil will change the texture substantially. Choose a suitable solid baking block, or use a cookie recipe written for oil.

Can I replace butter with margarine?

Use it 1:1 if the block or tub contains at least 80% fat. Low-fat toast spreads contain too much water for a dependable baking swap.

Can coconut oil replace butter?

Coconut oil can be used 1:1, solid for creaming or pastry and melted for melted-butter recipes. Refined coconut oil has no coconut taste, though the bake's texture can still change.

Can I use salted butter instead of unsalted?

Yes. Reduce the recipe's added salt by about 1/4 teaspoon per stick, or 1/2 cup (113 g), of butter.

Keep reading

Find a swap for where you cook

Paste a TikTok, Reel or YouTube recipe link into Pinchery to get written ingredients and steps, with ingredient swaps tuned to your country.

Open Pinchery

Works in your browser on Android, iPhone or a computer. Sign in with Google. Your first recipe is free.