Soy sauce substitute: choose by flavor and label

Tamari is a close swap when the soy sauce bottle is empty. Avoiding soy or gluten takes a different label check, and lighter color does not mean less salt.

Quick answer

Tamari is the closest soy sauce substitute: replace 1 tablespoon (15 ml) soy sauce with 1 tablespoon (15 ml) tamari. Check for a gluten-free label if that matters to you. For a soy-free option, use coconut aminos 1:1, then taste before adding a pinch of salt. They are sweeter and much less salty, so the finished sauce will taste different.

Choose a swap for your reason

Running out, avoiding gluten and avoiding soy are different problems. Liquid aminos can cover an empty bottle, but they contain soy. Many tamari bottles are gluten-free; the name alone does not guarantee it.

SwapAmount per 1 tablespoon (15 ml) soy sauceBest forWhat changes
Tamari1 tablespoon (15 ml), used 1:1A close flavor match; gluten-free cooking if labeledStill contains soy; check for wheat
Liquid aminos1 tablespoon (15 ml), used 1:1Seasoning when you have run outSoy-based, with similar saltiness
Coconut aminos1 tablespoon (15 ml), used 1:1A soy-free alternativeSweeter and much less salty; taste before adding salt
Fish sauceAbout 1 1/2 teaspoons (7.5 ml)Marinades and cooked saucesSaltier and pungent; contains fish and is not vegetarian
Miso and waterStart with 1 teaspoon (5 ml) miso, thinned with water to tasteCooked sauces and marinadesContains soy; adds a cloudy, thicker texture

Saltiness is only part of the job

Soy sauce is brewed from soybeans, usually wheat, salt and a koji mold, then aged. It seasons food and adds savory depth. Salt alone can replace the saltiness, but it cannot bring back the same flavor or brown color.

Add a swap cautiously when the recipe also contains salty ingredients. Low-sodium soy sauces exist if salt is your main concern. Coconut aminos are much less salty, but adding salt automatically would undo that advantage if your aim is to use less.

Light, dark and sweet soy sauces differ

LabelWhat it means for your recipe
Chinese light soy sauceThin and salty, used for seasoning; light describes the style
Chinese dark soy sauceThicker and slightly sweet, used mainly for color
Japanese koikuchi shoyuThe standard all-purpose Japanese soy sauce
Japanese usukuchi shoyuLighter in color but saltier
Indonesian kecap asinSalty soy sauce, the kind meant by plain "soy sauce"
Indonesian kecap manisThick, sweet soy sauce with palm sugar; not a 1:1 replacement

A recipe that specifically asks for dark soy sauce may lose its deep color with tamari or light soy sauce. Adding more to chase that color can make the food too salty.

Names outside the US

In Brazil, look for shoyu or molho de soja. French labels say sauce soja; German labels say Sojasauce. Spanish salsa de soja and Latin American salsa de soya refer to soy sauce. Read beyond the name to find the type the recipe needs.

Most soy sauces contain wheat. Many naturally brewed versions also contain a little alcohol from fermentation or added as a preservative. For halal requirements, look for an official halal logo.

When another sauce changes the dish

Oyster sauce adds sweetness and thickness, so it changes a simple dipping sauce considerably. Use the oyster sauce substitute guide if your recipe calls for both and you are deciding which role needs replacing.

Worcestershire can work in small amounts in a marinade, though it contains anchovies. Maggi seasoning is strong, so use less, and it contains wheat. Neither has a universal swap ratio here. If your marinade also calls for chili paste, the gochujang guide explains its role and substitutes.

Questions

What can I substitute for soy sauce without soy?

Coconut aminos work 1:1 by volume, though they are sweeter and much less salty. Tamari, miso and liquid aminos contain soy.

Is tamari always gluten-free?

No. Tamari is made with little or no wheat, so check the bottle for a gluten-free label rather than relying on the name.

Can I use fish sauce instead of soy sauce?

Use about half the amount, then taste. Fish sauce is more pungent and salty, so it works more comfortably in a marinade or cooked sauce than as a direct dipping-sauce replacement.

Keep reading

Match the sauce to your kitchen

Pinchery turns a TikTok, Reel, YouTube or recipe website link into a written recipe and offers ingredient swaps tuned to your country.

Open Pinchery

Works in your browser on Android, iPhone or a computer. Sign in with Google. Your first recipe is free.