Tomato paste substitute and the purée naming trap

A tube labeled tomato purée in the UK may already be what your American recipe needs. Pourable US tomato puree and passata need reducing to do the same job.

Quick answer

For a tomato paste substitute, use about 3 tablespoons (45 ml) passata, US tomato puree or tomato sauce per 1 tablespoon (15 ml) paste. Simmer it down, or add it to the dish with less other liquid and cook a few minutes longer. In the UK and Ireland, concentrated tomato purée is tomato paste, so you can use it as called for.

Swap amounts for sauce, stew or chili

The amounts below replace 1 tablespoon (15 ml) tomato paste. A seasoned sauce brings its own herbs and salt, so taste before adding more. In Australia, tomato sauce often means ketchup; use the ketchup row if that is your bottle.

SwapAmount per 1 tablespoon (15 ml) pasteBest forWhat changes
Passata, US tomato puree or US tomato sauceAbout 3 tablespoons (45 ml), reducedStews, chili and simmered saucesAdds water unless cooked down
Ketchup1 tablespoon (15 ml)Chili, barbecue sauce and meatloafSweeter, with vinegar and salt; reduce other sugar and salt
Chopped canned tomatoesCook down; concentration determines the amountDishes with time to simmerNeeds reducing; pieces may remain
Sun-dried tomatoesBlend to a paste; adjust the amount to tasteSauces that suit a stronger tomato flavorMore intense and a little sweet

Why a thin tomato sauce needs reducing

Tomato paste adds concentrated, sweet-savory tomato flavor and red color with very little extra liquid. It also thickens a stew or sauce slightly. Pouring in a thin substitute can leave the dish watery before you have added enough tomato flavor.

In the US, tomato paste has at least 24% tomato solids. Tomato puree has 8-24%, which explains why the same spoonful does a different job. The name alone can be misleading when the recipe and the label come from different countries.

Cook a thinner swap down first

  1. Measure about 3 tablespoons (45 ml) passata, US tomato puree or sauce for each 1 tablespoon (15 ml) paste needed.
  2. Simmer in a small pan, stirring as it thickens, until it looks concentrated rather than pourable. Follow the texture instead of a fixed timer.
  3. Add it to your dish. If you reduce it in the dish instead, use a little less of the other liquid and allow a few extra minutes of cooking.

Actual tomato paste benefits from a different step: stir it in hot oil for a minute or two, until it darkens a shade. That deepens its flavor and takes away the tinny taste. A watery sauce needs its water cooked off before it can behave similarly.

If you are also changing the batch size, use the recipe scaler for the original amounts, then apply the swap.

Tomato purée means different things by country

WhereConcentrated product to look for
UK and IrelandTomato purée, usually in a tube
GermanyTomatenmark, including 2-fach or 3-fach konzentriert
FranceConcentré de tomate, including double or triple concentré
ItalyConcentrato di pomodoro, including doppio or triplo concentrato
MexicoPasta de tomate; puré de tomate is thinner
BrazilExtrato de tomate; molho de tomate and polpa are thinner

Italian passata is pourable tomato, so do not treat it as concentrated paste. Check the consistency and wording on the pack before deciding you need a substitute.

When color is not enough

Roasted red pepper paste, harissa and gochujang can make a sauce red, but each changes its flavor. Harissa and gochujang can also add heat. The gochujang guide explains the fermented chili paste before you put it in a tomato-based recipe.

Choose tomato paste when a dish depends on concentrated tomato flavor with very little moisture, or when extra simmering would overcook the other ingredients. Freeze leftover canned paste in tablespoon portions so the next recipe needs less improvising.

Questions

Is UK tomato purée the same as tomato paste?

Yes. Concentrated tomato purée sold in the UK and Ireland is what an American recipe calls tomato paste. US tomato puree is thinner.

Can I substitute ketchup for tomato paste?

Use the same volume in chili, barbecue sauce or meatloaf. Ketchup adds sugar, vinegar and salt, so reduce the other sugar and salt and expect a tangier result.

Can passata replace tomato paste?

Use about 3 tablespoons (45 ml) passata per 1 tablespoon (15 ml) paste and simmer it down. If you cook it down in the dish, reduce the other liquid a little.

Keep reading

Make sense of an American recipe

Paste the recipe website, TikTok or Reel link into Pinchery for written ingredients and steps, with ingredient swaps tuned to your country.

Open Pinchery

Works in your browser on Android, iPhone or a computer. Sign in with Google. Your first recipe is free.